OSHA Opposes California High-Silica Ban
WASHINGTON – The federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration is advising California not to ban high-silica-content engineered stone.

In a Nov. 16 letter from David L. Keeling, an assistant secretary at the Labor Department, the federal workplace safety agency advocated increased enforcement of current regulations and more industry education.
“While we acknowledge the seriousness and severity of the silicosis problem, OSHA believes the prohibition of engineered stone is an excessive and unnecessary action,” Keeling wrote to Jennifer Osborn, director of the California Department of Industrial Relations.
Keeling wrote that OSHA “carefully reviewed” proposed emergency regulations by state workplace-safety Cal/OSHA concerning the banning of fabrication and use of engineered stone with 1% or more of crystalline-silica material
The letter also stated that OSHA also acknowledged the “tenfold” increase in over three years of silicosis cases among California workers, but “we are not aware of a comparative increase in any other jurisdictions during that timeframe.”
OSHA also noted that a ban would treat shops with and without compliant safety equipment equally, and “this approach eliminates any incentive for employers to invest in and improve safety compliance.”
Since California doesn’t control the entire supply chain with engineered stone, OSHA stated that some non-compliant shops “may move underground, concentrating on risk in the least regulated settings.
In the letter, the federal agency argued that California’s data “reveals the inadequacy of resources allocated to appropriate enforcement and education strategies.
“A categorical prohibition will not solve this problem but may even exacerbate it. Cal/OSHA would need to expend as many, or more, resources inspecting for compliance with the one percent standard than it does under existing rules,” according to OSHA.
OSHA recommended “rigorous implementation and enforcement of existing standards and guidance,” noting that OSHA’s crystalline-silica standards and focused inspections “have proven to be workable in other industries.”
“These should be used as models for Cal/OSHA’s adoption and use,” Keeling wrote.
“OSHA urges Cal/OSHA to adopt a targeted enforcement strategy that protects workers, rewards compliance, and holds violators accountable,” Keeling concluded. “OSHA stands ready to support this shared goal.”
Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling announced the letter on a Nov. 19 post on X, noting it was issued “at my direction.”





